The Forgotten Tragedy of the Sea Wing: Minnesota's Titanic Story

​

In the annals of history, some events are destined to fade into obscurity, known only to those who were directly impacted. Such is the case with the tragic maritime disaster of the Sea Wing, an event that has largely remained confined to the memory of the small river town of Red Wing, Minnesota. However, the Sea Wing disaster of July 13, 1890, left a profound mark on this community, claiming the lives of 98 passengers and altering the trajectory of countless families forever.

The Sea Wing was a steamship that had embarked on a seemingly joyful excursion down the Mississippi River. It was a day filled with anticipation, as passengers danced to the tunes of a four-string band and enjoyed popcorn, lemonade, and ice cream. The pleasure cruise had been dubbed the "social event of the season," drawing people from far and wide.

But, as often happens, nature can be unpredictable. On that fateful day, a sudden and violent storm descended upon Lake Pepin. The once-celebratory atmosphere turned to chaos as the ship capsized, trapping many inside the passenger cabin. Ninety-eight passengers, nearly half of those on board, met a tragic end, either tossed into the churning waters or submerged within the capsized vessel.

The tragedy was compounded by the fact that many of the passengers were ill-prepared for such a disaster. Of the 57 females on board, 50 of them perished. Their heavy fabrics and long dresses made swimming nearly impossible. Whole families were lost, young couples torn apart, and children left without parents. Red Wing bore the brunt of this loss, with 77 of the 98 victims hailing from this close-knit community.

In the aftermath of the disaster, Red Wing became a city of mourning and grief, hosting round after round of funerals and wakes. Survivors were burdened with lifelong sorrow, their lives forever altered. Heartache permeated the lives of those who had lost loved ones. John Staiger, whose daughters Annie and Frances perished, would sit and cry daily as he gazed at their pictures in his family's best room.

The recovery of bodies was a harrowing process, and families held out hope for their loved ones' survival. Eliza Crawford, a dedicated teacher who had just completed her first month of teaching, was among the missing. Her uncle, H.W. Keller, refrained from informing the family about her possible death, only to later discover her among the drowning victims.

Despite its magnitude, the Sea Wing disaster remains relatively unknown beyond the borders of Red Wing. It's often referred to as Minnesota's Titanic story, yet its historical memory has not penetrated far beyond the city's immediate vicinity. Why is this the case?

Part of the answer lies in the localization of the tragedy. Red Wing suffered the greatest loss, with the rest of the victims coming from neighboring Wisconsin. This regional concentration likely contributed to the limited awareness of the disaster beyond the area.

Furthermore, as the older generations who remembered the Sea Wing disaster passed away, the event faded from public consciousness. It became a topic seldom discussed, especially among those further removed from the epicenter of the tragedy.

The sensationalism of the media at the time also played a role in shaping the historical narrative. While the horror of the event required no embellishment, headlines often veered into the realm of tabloid sensationalism, with phrases like "A Voyage of Pleasure That Ended on the Shores of Another World" and "The Tornado on Pepin's Bosom, the crowning calamity of all Minnesota Annals."

Conflicting narratives arose, many of them centered on the ship's pilot and co-owner, David Wethern. Questions swirled about his judgment and conduct, particularly why he chose to navigate the ship despite ominous weather conditions. Inspectors later charged him with "unskillfulness" for not hugging Minnesota's shoreline where harbors could have provided protection.

Despite the controversy surrounding Wethern, he remained a figure of social standing in the community. His personal loss, having lost his wife and child in the disaster, garnered sympathy from those who had initially criticized him.

In the end, the Sea Wing disaster, though a devastating chapter in Minnesota's history, has largely remained confined to the collective memory of Red Wing and its immediate surroundings. It serves as a reminder that even the most tragic events can be forgotten over time if not actively preserved in the pages of history. The Sea Wing, with its lost lives and shattered families, is a story that deserves to be remembered, not only for the lessons it imparts but also as a testament to the resilience of a community in the face of unimaginable sorrow.